"Community",
Adaptation and the Vietnamese in Toronto |
By Mark Edward Pfeifer
Ó Copyright by Mark Edward Pfeifer
(1999)
Abstract/Acknowledgements/Table
of Contents - [ Chapters - 1 - 2 - 3 - 4 - 5 - 6 - 7 - 8 - 9 - 10 - 11 ] - Appendices - References
Cited
CHAPTER THREE
AN OVERVIEW OF VIETNAMESE HISTORY,
CULTURE, AND SOCIAL STRUCTURE
A BRIEF HISTORY OF THE VIETNAMESE PEOPLE
Historians disagree concerning the precise origin of the Vietnamese
people. Many writers have assumed that the Vietnamese are direct descendants of the Viets,
a group of persons that inhabited land south of the Yangtze River in China. According to
this theory, the various tribes of the Viets were gradually driven further and further
south into the Red River delta of present-day North Vietnam by the expanding Chinese
empire. Subsequently, it is argued, the first Vietnamese state was founded in the Red
River region in the time period of 300 B.C. (Buttinger, 1968).
Some of the most prominent scholars of Vietnamese history have come to
reject portions of this explanation. These historians have argued that the origins of the
Vietnamese people reflect an amalgamation of persons from Southern China with the
indigenous persons of the surrounding regions of Southeast Asia (Woodside, 1988; Jamieson,
1993; Chapius, 1995). Buttinger (1968) in his seminal history of Vietnam argues that a
complex racial and cultural fusion occurred in the area of the Red River Valley. This
fusion involved the Viet peoples from China, Thai peoples, as well as persons of
Indonesian origin who for several centuries dominated the Red River Delta. In sum,
Buttinger concludes that not only archaeological finds but language research as well
confirms the mixed racial and cultural origins of the Vietnamese. He notes that while the
Vietnamese do speak a distinctly separate language, close analysis demonstrates that their
language contains important elements from the Mon-Khmer and Thai languages. According to
Buttinger, Chinese elements enriched the Vietnamese language at a later stage in the
Vietnamese civilization.
After 300 B.C., the Vietnamese gradually moved southward from the Red
River region. However, it wasn't until the 16th century A.D. that Vietnamese civilization
expanded into present-day South Vietnam, down to the Mekong River Delta. Prior to this
time, the Indianized cultures of the Funan and the Champa (or Khmer) Kingdoms controlled
this territory. Persons of Khmer ethnic origin, known as Chams, still constitute a
minority group within Vietnam (Buttinger, 1968; Woodside, 1988).
Regardless of the precise origins of Vietnamese civilization, it is
indisputable that Chinese influences have strongly shaped the development of Vietnamese
culture. The history of Vietnam has been profoundly affected by the imperialistic
behaviour of its northern neighbour. The Chinese gained political control of Vietnam in
111 B.C. With the exception of a few brief interludes, Chinese rule continued in Vietnam
until a series of uprisings in the 10th century. 939 A.D. is the year from which the
Vietnamese commonly date the beginning of their national independence (Buttinger, 1968;
Chapius, 1995). After the 18th century Vietnam's sovereignty was again challenged, this
time by the imperialistic ambitions of the French. France gained effective political
control of the nation with the 1863 signing of a treaty with the Vietnamese Emperor Tu
Duc. This treaty extended French authority over the whole of Vietnam. French control was
the stimulus for the development of a strong nationalist movement. After decades of
agitation by Vietnamese nationalists, the Geneva agreement was signed in 1954. This treaty
stipulated that Vietnam would be divided at the 17th parallel into two military zones. The
Communist Viet Minh forces were to retreat north of the dividing line, the French and
Republic of Vietnam troops south of it (Buttinger, 1968). By the early 1960s, the United
States had replaced France as the primary backers of the South Vietnamese government.
Fighting between South and North Vietnamese forces for control of the entire country came
to an end with the Fall of Saigon to the communist regime of the North in April 1975.
VIETNAMESE CULTURAL VALUES, SOCIAL
ORGANIZATION AND FAMILY STRUCTURE
After their introduction from China over the centuries as separate
religious systems, Confucianism, Buddhism, and Taoism merged into a unique philosophical
and religious perspective, often referred to as the Tam Giao. This basic system of common
values is shared to a certain extent by most Vietnamese (Hanh, 1967; Thien-An, 1975;
Rutledge, 1985; Jamieson, 1993). Central to the syncretic belief system of the Tam Giao is
its conception of family relations. The family is the basic institution established by the
Vietnamese to ensure physical, emotional, and social stability for its members and to
promulgate societal norms and standards (Rutledge, 1992). Traditionally, the Vietnamese
have regarded the patrilineal extended family as vitally important to the perpetuation of
Vietnamese cultural values. The traditional Vietnamese family hierarchy is strongly
influenced by Confucian ideals intended to explain and legitimize all social relations.
Following the Confucian tradition, the relations between the king and his people are
similar to those linking the father with his wife and children. The family is thus
regarded as the entity upon which the entire social system is modeled. A code of behaviour
regulates all relations within the traditional Vietnamese family and specifies the duties
and obligations of each family member. A set of rules guides the proper way of addressing
relatives, appropriate gestures and body positions in given situations, and the order of
precedence during family meals and religious ceremonies (Dorais et al., 1987).
Reverence for ancestors is a key component of the Tam Giao ideology and
belief system. The Vietnamese family entity is conceived of as including obligations to
both the deceased as well as the living. The traditional Vietnamese home includes an
ancestral altar, where the spirits of deceased relatives are believed to reside.
Ancestors, including parents, siblings, and grandparents, are worshipped annually in
ceremonies commemorating the anniversary date of their death. Ancestors are invoked during
regular family prayers at the altar as well as on the occasions of engagements, marriages,
and funerals of family members. Ancestor worship is also a key component in the formal
religious ceremonies of the major Vietnamese religions of Buddhism and Cao Daism (Dorais,
1989; Muzny, 1989).
The Vietnamese family ideology involves a set of role-based behavioural
ideals. These ideals instill in the Vietnamese a rigid code of conduct, a strong sense of
duty to other family members, and often a great deal of guilt. The primacy of family ties
is central to the traditional Vietnamese belief system. Crucially, in Vietnamese culture,
the family is considered to be more important than the individual. The family is conceived
of as the central means of economic and social support. All family members turn over their
earnings for the usage of the entire family. The larger family also determines the
acceptability of marriage partners (Muzny, 1989). Going against family obligations is
perceived as being contrary to the natural order of the world. Behaviour that is in
oppositon to this natural order is perceived to inevitably result in negative consequences
(or bad karma) not only for individuals but for their entire families as well (Jamieson,
1993).
The traditional Vietnamese family is patrilineal and extended in its
organization. The parents, the sons and their wives, unmarried daughters, grandparents,
and uncles and aunts may all reside in the Vietnamese household. The roles within the
family are well-defined. The father is considered to be the head of the family unit and
responsible for economic decisions, maintaining family traditions and leading the family
in ancestor worship. The father is always to be accorded great respect. The eldest son is
expected to never leave his parents and to continue living at the family home with his
wife and children. After the death of his father, the eldest son becomes the head of the
household, taking ultimate responsibility for decison-making and carrying on ancestral
traditions. After marriage, other sons may create new households, preferably in close
geographic proximity to the parents. However, unmarried daughters must always live with
their parents (Muzny, 1989; Rutledge, 1992).
According to the traditional family ideology, the main duty of a
Vietnamese woman is to care for her husband and his family. After marriage, the wife is
expected to become a member of the husband's family with obligations to respect and care
for her in-laws. Under the traditional Vietnamese family model, women are expected to
engage in housekeeping, cooking, and rearing the children while depending on male
household members to financially support the family. A Vietnamese woman is taught to
submit to her father while under his care, obey her husband following marriage, and to
listen to her eldest son in widowhood (Muzny, 1989; Rutledge, 1992). It should be noted
that some scholars have questioned the extent to which such rigidly prescribed gender
roles reflect the actual contributions of Vietnamese women to their families in Vietnam
and North America. Hickey (1964) and Rutledge (1992) note that in the Vietnamese home, the
mother is usually responsible for harmony among family members, coordinating the schedules
of family members and managing the family budget. Indeed, all family members, including
the male household head, typically submit their earnings to the mother, who makes
financial decisions for the family as a unified whole. Haines (1986) and Woon (1986)
observe that Vietnamese women have for centuries engaged in petty commerce outside of the
household to support their families and during the war years of the 1950s to the 1970s,
many families were broken up, at least temporarily, with men fighting in the military, and
women joining the workforce and providing the primary financial support for their
families.
Scholars have documented the continuation of collective family
behaviour among Vietnamese immigrants and refugees in Canada and the United States (Woon,
1986; Rutledge, 1992; Hein, 1995). In her ethnographic study of Vietnamese families in
Philadelphia, Kibria (1993) refers to these collective practices as
"patchworking." She defines patchworking as a bringing together and sharing of
resources among the divergent members of a household. Kibria observed that her research
informants brought with them to the U.S, a collective, cooperative approach toward
economic resources and activities among household members, which stressed and idealized
the unity of family or kin group interests over that of the individual. Kibria notes that
among her Vietnamese informants there was a strong belief that kinship ties could serve as
a useful economic safety net. Kinship was perceived of as the most reliable source of
support for the individual - the only institution that could be relied upon for assistance
in all circumstances.
Kibria notes that in the U.S., Vietnamese persons quickly go about
rebuilding and/or creating new kinship groups for the purpose of sharing economic as well
as other resources such as child care, language skills, and information about the host
society and its institutions. Importantly, Kibria points out that the rebuilding of kin
groups among the Vietnamese is made easier by the existence of cultural kinship traditions
that define the boundaries of the kin group in an inclusive manner. Distant relatives such
as cousins as well as individuals unrelated by traditional criteria may be defined in
familial terms such as "brother" or "sister" for the purpose of
economic exchange and resource sharing. Kibria provides examples of unrelated young
Vietnamese "brothers" who formed households in order to collectively pool
material resources and provide one another with social support.
Significantly, migration to North America has also led to role changes
among men and women and some conflict within Vietnamese families. In North America, many
Vietnamese women have become significant income earners for their families. While it was
not uncommon for women to work outside the home in Vietnam, men were considered to be the
primary breadwinners of the household. In Canada and the United States, the relative
financial contribution of women to Vietnamese families has increased greatly. In pre-1975
South Vietnam, many Vietnamese immigrant and refugee men had held middle-class occupations
in the government or as military officers. Upon coming to North America, many of these
same men encountered unemployment or much lower status work in the lower tiers of the
occupational structure as a result of language difficulties, a lack of transferable
skills, and/or employment discrimination. At the same time, many Vietnamese women have
also found jobs in the informal and secondary sectors of the labour market, earning
equivalent incomes to Vietnamese men. This shift in the balance of resources among genders
is a source of tension and change in the relations of Vietnamese men and women (Kibria,
1989; Kibria, 1990; Rutledge, 1992; Kibria, 1993; Kibria, 1994).
Importantly, Kibria (1993) points out that the shift in the balance of
resources occurring between men and women has not resulted in a radical restructuring of
gender relations within Vietnamese families. According to Kibria, Vietnamese-American
women are exercising greater influence in the decision-making processes within their
families because of their relatively greater control over resources in comparison to the
past, but for the most part they have not utilized this increased power to challenge
traditional Vietnamese cultural conceptions of gender relations and family life.
Overall, Kibria concludes that many Vietnamese immigrant and refugee
women continue to support the ideology of the traditional family system. Women's support
of this system reflects the power it affords them as mothers as well as the perceived
necessity of the family system for personal economic support. Kibria notes that among her
informants, both men and women saw the collective household economy as key to their
ability to survive and attain socioeconomic mobility. This collective household economy
was centred upon and legitimated by the traditional Vietnamese family ideology. Within the
context of an uncertain economic environment, Vietnamese immigrant women valued the power
of the traditional family system to support and uphold men's and children's obligations to
the larger family unit.
In the traditional Vietnamese family, children are taught to have
respect for their parents and elders in general. These principles of filial piety,
respect, and duty to the family include a responsibility for providing for one's parents
in their old age (Rutledge, 1992). The roles of children have also been changing in many
Vietnamese immigrant and refugee families. Traditional Vietnamese family values are tested
by the North American cultural emphasis on individualism. Many of the more acculturated
Vietnamese young people resist turning over their earnings to the larger family. The
freedom to date among young people of the opposite gender, which is especially frowned
upon for females, is also a source of conflict between parents and children in Vietnamese
families (Rutledge, 1992; Kibria, 1993). In many households, English language fluency and
greater fluency and familiarity with the procedures of bureaucracies and state
institutions has resulted in enhanced power and freedom for young people and a general
decline in parental authority within Vietnamese families. In situations of interaction
with the larger society, the parents often come to rely upon the children. This reliance
creates a reversal from traditional Vietnamese roles and sometimes results in a form of
intergenerational conflict within families as parents feel a loss of power and status and
children do not feel they earn the respect they deserve from their parents given their
everyday importance to the family (Rutledge, 1992; Kibria, 1993) .
THE SOCIAL STRUCTURE IN VIETNAM
Until the past few decades, the vast majority of Vietnamese lived
an agrarian life-style. The village was the primary social system with which Vietnamese
interacted outside of their immediate families. Village affairs were conducted in the
communal house, where all official documents pertaining to the village were deposited.
Individual villages possessed their own laws, which were a mixture of administrative
rules, customary laws, as well as religious guidelines associated with a village deity. In
addition to the communal administrative centre, each village also had its own temple,
market area, and social service delivery system. Individual villages typically negotiated
economic arrangements with regional governments to export cultivated crops and bring
income into the area (Hickey, 1964; Ho Tai, 1987).
Since the 1950s, the agrarian way of life and village superstructure
has remained far more intact in the Northern portion of the country compared to the
Central and especially Southern regions. As the Vietnam War escalated in the late 1950s
and early 1960s, the United States contributed extensive funds and technical assistance to
South Vietnam. With the help of U.S. financial contributions, the number of students
attending school in the Republic of Vietnam doubled between 1955 and 1960 and doubled
again by 1969. The number of radio sets in South Vietnam soared from an estimated 125,000
units in 1960 to 2,200,000 in 1970. Television was introduced to South Vietnam in 1966. By
1969, an estimated two million viewers were reached through nearly 300,000 privately owned
sets and approximately 3,000 community sets. At the same time, rapid urbanization was
taking place. In 1945, the population of Saigon was about half a million. By 1954, it was
about two million. The size of the city approached three million in 1965 (Jamieson, 1993).
The growing U.S. presence under the regime of Ngo Dinh Diem in the late
1950s and early 1960s directly contributed to the strong influence of American culture in
the Southern portion of the country. The social and cultural environment in South Vietnam
came to reflect an amalgamation of Vietnamese, French, and American values. Crucially,
U.S. economic and technological assistance was the stimulus for the rise of an affluent
middle class composed of government officials, military officers, professionals, and
merchants (Duiker, 1995).
It was this new middle class which felt the most severe discomfort and
hardship after the Fall of Saigon in 1975. Many South Vietnamese men were forcibly sent to
"reeducation camps" created by the Communist regime for the purpose of
indoctrinating and punishing those with ties to the former government. Poor living
conditions and heavy labour were common in the camps. Some South Vietnamese were forced to
move to the so-called "New Economic Zones." These were tracts of land that had
been abandoned or damaged by the war. The "New Economic Zones" were designed to
reduce the population burden on overcrowded urban centres in South Vietnam and to
reintroduce cultivation to non-productive land. Many of the Vietnamese who were forced to
relocate had led urban lifestyles before 1975. Conditions were difficult in these barren
rural areas for Vietnamese who had little desire or propensity for agricultural work
(Strand and Jones, 1985; Kibria, 1993)
The urban middle class residents of South Vietnam suffered severe
losses in status after the rise of the Communists. Children of former army officers or
governmental officials were often discriminated against and denied admittance to the top
educational institutions. After 1978, the government began a policy of nationalizing many
private businesses. For many South Vietnamese merchants (including a large
Chinese-Vietnamese mercantile class), business ownership severely declined in
profitability. Unemployment became a serious problem as former army officers, bureaucrats,
and businessmen lost their jobs. Compounding the above difficulties was a drought in 1977,
followed by floods, which exacerbated already existing land cultivation problems caused by
military mining and herbicides. Food became scarce. Given these conditions, many South
Vietnamese, particularly the former urban elite and middle class, felt an acute sense of
political persecution and financial desperation, which compelled them to attempt to escape
the country (Strand and Jones, 1985; Kibria, 1993).
THE ETHNIC CHINESE MINORITY IN VIETNAM
The history of Chinese
immigration into Vietnam goes back over two thousand years. In Vietnam, ethnic Chinese
developed their own residential communities, each with its own institutions, including
religious centres, schools, shops, and political organizations. Gradually over the years,
the Chinese-Vietnamese came to accept a variety of Vietnamese cultural norms. However,
while some inter-marriage did occur, most Chinese continued to consider themselves as
ethnically separate and maintained usage of their ancestral language (Strand and Jones,
1985; Whitmore, 1985; Desbarats, 1986).
The maintenance of close ties with China, along with this distinct
ethnic identity, created tensions between the ethnic Chinese and the Vietnamese majority.
Conflict was exacerbated by the traditional "middlemen" occupations held by
significant numbers of ethnic Chinese in Vietnam. A disproportionate number of
Chinese-Vietnamese resided in urban centres and worked as merchants and money lenders. As
a consequence of Vietnamese resentment of ethnic Chinese wealth, the Chinese were over
time subject to several repressive governmental measures designed to end their economic
control over trade and retail activities. These actions were undertaken by several
emperors, the Viet Minh in the North after the 1940s, as well as the Diem regime, which
ruled the South in 1950s and 1960s (Strand and Jones, 1985).
Tensions between the Vietnamese government and the Chinese-Vietnamese
population intensified following reunification in 1975. The Communist government attempted
to integrate the sizable Chinese population in the heavily urbanized South with the rest
of the nation. In early 1976, ethnic Chinese residents were required to register their
citizenship. Those who retained Chinese status were subjected to heavy taxes, job
discrimination, and a reduction of food rations. In the Fall of 1976, all Chinese schools
and newspapers were closed. In early 1977, those Chinese-Vietnamese who had registered as
Chinese citizens were dismissed from their government jobs and prohibited from public
enterprise and retail trade. Food rations were terminated and the free movement of
Chinese-Vietnamese within Vietnam was forbidden. In addition, the property of many ethnic
Chinese was seized and several thousand Chinese were expelled from the country (Strand and
Jones, 1985).
By the summer of 1978, more than 160,000 Chinese-Vietnamese had fled
into China. Several thousand more left the former South Vietnam by boat. Indeed,
Chinese-Vietnamese constituted a disproportionate number of the "Boat People",
who escaped from Vietnam in the late 1970s and early 1980s. As of 1980, at least 400,000
ethnic Chinese "Boat People" had escaped persecution in Vietnam. By the
mid-1980s, the ethnic Chinese population of Vietnam was estimated to be practically
non-existent (Strand and Jones, 1985).
It is difficult to find accurate estimates of the Chinese-Vietnamese
population in Canada or the United States. It is likely that former ethnic Chinese
residents of Vietnam identify themselves to census takers alternately as Chinese or
Vietnamese. However, it is clear that the Chinese-Vietnamese should be considered a
distinct ethnic group with a culture and history quite different from that experienced by
the ethnic Vietnamese or other major subgroups of the Chinese population.
MAJOR VIETNAMESE RELIGIONS
Throughout Vietnams
history, religious affiliation has been a key factor influencing the social and class
structure of the nation. All of the major Vietnamese religions have long carried strong
connotations for the personal identity of their followers, given the unique development
and important role of each in Vietnam's history. The following is a discussion of the some
of the key characteristics and historic experiences associated with the largest religious
subgroups found within Vietnam.
Buddhists - Prior to 1975, over 70% of the entire population of
all regions of Vietnam was considered to be Buddhist (Canh, 1983; Rutledge, 1985).
Mahayana Buddhism - the branch of Buddhism observed by over 90% of Vietnamese Buddhists -
was introduced to Vietnam in the second century A.D. by the Chinese (Hanh, 1967). In
almost every village in Vietnam there is a Buddhist pagoda (chua). In many villages, the
village common house (dinh), which functions as a meeting site and a place for the worship
of the village spirit protector, is also located in the pagoda complex (Hanh, 1967,
McClellan, 1993). In addition to its religious functions, the Buddhist temple has also
served as a centre for social interaction and the provision of mutual aid among villagers.
Throughout Vietnam, Buddhist schools and universities were established as well as
Buddhist-run orphanages and hospitals (Hanh, 1967).
Over the past two centuries, Vietnamese Buddhist identity has become
strongly intertwined with a fervent nationalistic sentiment. These nationalist feelings
have been fuelled by the antagonisms between Vietnamese Buddhists and Catholics. After the
French conquest of Vietnam in the latter half of the 19th century, French
officials accorded open support to the Vietnamese Roman Catholic Church. Catholic churches
and missionaries were not restricted in their work, while other religionists were (Hanh,
1967). Most followers of Buddhism associated themselves with a variety of resistance
forces, which fought the French colonizers. While a sizable number of Vietnamese Catholics
also participated in the resistance, Catholics as a group were widely suspected of
collaborating with the French.
Many Vietnamese, especially the rural villagers, believed that Buddhism
and Confucianism were the proper religions of Vietnam, whereas Christianity was perceived
to be the religion of the westerners, and the French in particular. In the perception of
many Buddhists, to embrace Christianity meant to side with the colonizers. As French
forces destroyed villages and burned down Buddhist pagodas and other structures,
resistance leaders ordered the destruction and the burning of Catholic churches in
reprisal (Hanh, 1967; Gheddo, 1970).
Buddhist nationalism and conflict with Catholics were key variables in
the opposition movement to South Vietnamese president Ngo Dinh Diem in the early 1960s.
Buddhists were angered by the perceived favouritism shown to Catholics by President Diem,
himself a Catholic. Many of the most prominent positions within his South Vietnamese
government and military were held by Catholics. In addition, President Diem's brother
served as a powerful archbishop in the Vietnamese Roman Catholic church. Many Buddhists
resented the disproportionate influence of the well-educated and prosperous Catholic
elite.
Buddhist opposition to the Diem regime broke into the open in May 1963
at the city of Hue in central Vietnam. May 8 was the anniversary of the death of the
Buddha and the Buddhist faithful were preparing to celebrate religious festivals in the
city of Hue, the centre of Vietnamese Buddhism, and a city of ancient Buddhist tradition.
A few days before the festival, the Diem government forbade the carrying of religious
banners through the streets of Vietnamese cities. The government ordered the local police
to enforce the law outlawing the display of religious flags. On the day of the
anniversary, 10,000 Vietnamese Buddhist clashed with the police. Eight died and twenty
were wounded in the incident. Subsequently, in the summer of 1963, several Vietnamese
Buddhist monks and nuns immolated themselves to show their opposition to the policies of
the Diem government and its perceived persecution of Buddhists (Hanh, 1967; Gheddo, 1970).
President Diem was assassinated and his regime overthrown in November 1963. After 1975,
officials of the Communist regime took strong measures against Buddhists. Buddhist pagodas
and other properties were confiscated throughout South and Central Vietnam and converted
to government buildings. At the same time, thousands of Buddhist monks and nuns were put
in prison or were forced to work in rural communes (Canh, 1983).
Catholics - Prior to 1975, Catholics constituted approximately
10-15% of the total population of Vietnam (Rutledge, 1985). The first Catholic
missionaries to arrive in Vietnam were the Spanish and Portuguese in the 16th century.
These first efforts at evangelization were renewed by the Jesuits in the 17th century. The
French priest Alexander de Rhodes landed on the coast of North Vietnam in 1627 and he and
his fellow Jesuits encountered great success in converting many Vietnamese in this region
to Catholicism. By 1663 there were about 200,000 Catholics among the 2,000,000 Tonkinese.
Missionaries met with somewhat less success in South Vietnam, but by the 1660s there were
another 100,000 Vietnamese Catholics in the southern portion of the nation. Among other
exploits, Father de Rhodes was also responsible for the romanization of the Vietnamese
language (Gheddo, 1970).
Subsequent Vietnamese emperors directed periodic violent persecutions
against the Catholic population beginning in the late 17th century and lasting until the
mid-19th century. In these waves of harassment, churches were destroyed and Catholic
villages were burned as the faithful were commonly forced to trample on the cross and
offer sacrifices to Buddhist and other traditional Vietnamese idols. In the two centuries
of severe persecution, the Vietnamese Catholic church accumulated approximately 130,000
martyrs, several hundred of whom have been beatified by successive popes (Gheddo, 1970).
The collective memory of these indigenous martyrs and saints as well as
that of other Vietnamese Catholics who were persecuted in later decades, constitutes a
central component of the Vietnamese-Catholic identity. Vietnamese-Catholics have always
perceived themselves as being a minority group within Vietnam. To escape persecution and
to avoid requirements that they worship the village god, rural Vietnamese Catholics
seceded from native villages and established new ones under the leadership of parish
priests. Frequently, these new villages were founded adjacent to already existing ones. At
times, however, priests led their parishioners into undeveloped areas and founded new
villages. Catholics throughout Vietnam developed "super-village" enclaves, in
which were based complex institutional systems of mutual assistance. Catholics established
their own hospitals, newspapers, schools, universities, and military units (Gheddo, 1970;
Ho Tai, 1987; Jamieson, 1993).
After the Geneva Conference in 1954, which divided Vietnam into two
countries, the Communist government of the North began severe persecutions of
predominantly Catholic villages in several regions of North Vietnam. At the end of 1954,
nearly 800,000 Vietnamese, mostly Catholics, left their homes in North Vietnam as refugees
to come to South Vietnam. The perceived special treatment given to these refugees by the
South Vietnamese government of Ngo Dinh Diem, helped provoke the conflict between
Buddhists and Catholics, which peaked with the overthrow of the Diem regime in 1963 (Hanh,
1967). Under Diem, Catholic refugees were resettled in the suburbs of Saigon and in Rural
Development Centres in the Central region, in part to serve as a basis of support for the
anti-Communist regime. Catholics were also given prominent positions in the government and
the armed forces. Many Catholics took on major roles in commerce, the professions, and in
cultural affairs (Duiker, 1995). After the Communist takeover in 1975, hundreds of priests
and nuns were arrested, churches were seized or monitored, and the separate Catholic
social, educational, and medical establishments were taken over by the state. Given their
previous experiences with the Communists and strong association with the South Vietnamese
regime, it is not surprising that Catholics constituted a disproportionate share of the
refugees and immigrants who left Vietnam after 1975.
Cao Dai - Caodaism is an indigenous Vietnamese religion that
originated in South Vietnam in the 1920s. Caodaism is syncretic in its organizational
structure, philosophy, theology, and ritual practices. The primary influences are Mahayana
Buddhism, Confucianism, Taoism, and spiritualism, with some elements drawn from
Christianity as well. The synthesis of elements adapted from other religious systems may
be observed in the Cao Dai practices of priestly celibacy, vegetarianism, seance inquiry
and spirit communication, homage to ancestors and prayers for the dead, meditative
self-cultivation, and proselytism (Oliver, 1976; Phan Van Phuoc, personal interview, July
14, 1996).
The original Cao Dai Holy See was established at Tay Ninh, about 100 km
north of Saigon. After its official establishment in 1926, Cao Dai quickly gained an
impressive following of two million persons residing in portions of Southern and Central
Vietnam. By the 1950s, by one estimate, approximately 1/8 of the South Vietnamese
population practiced Cao Dai. Caodaism attracted significant numbers of followers from all
classes of Vietnamese including nationalistic but anti-Communist civil servants as well as
village peasants. In certain strongholds of South and Central Vietnam, Cao Dai adherents
constituted a majority of the region's population and like Catholics in some regions,
formed their own schools, hospitals, orphanages and social delivery systems within
autonomous "super-village" social structures (Jamieson, 1993).
Cao Dai followers also came to represent a major political and military
bloc in South Vietnam. From 1926 to 1956, the major elements of the Cao Dai armed forces
were incorporated into the South Vietnamese army. The strength of the Cao Dai influence in
political affairs may also be observed in the composition of the National Congress which
was formed in the early 1950s to discuss the terms of a Vietnamese independence treaty
with the French. The Cao Dai were awarded 17 seats at this congress, the largest
delegation of any of the major politico-religious groups operating in South Vietnam at the
time, including the Buddhists and the Catholics (Oliver, 1976). After 1975, the Communist
regime arrested and detained most of the Cao Dai leaders including the church's papal
hierarchy. The Cao Dai's Holy See in Tay Ninh province was confiscated and village temples
were shut down. The actions of the communists followed a long history of attempts by
authorities to suppress the influence of Caodaism. In the 1930s, Cao Dai temples were
closed and key personnel were imprisoned by the French for their perceived nationalistic
activities (Oliver, 1976). During the second Vietnam War (1958-1975), the leaders of South
Vietnam worked to reduce or eliminate the political and military power of Cao Dai leaders.
As a result of this religious and political persecution many adherents of Cao Daism
developed a strong minority identity, inhabiting close knit communities in regions where
they were numerically concentrated, a factor which has helped stimulate the development of
Cao Dai congregations in regions of Vietnamese resettlement and migration including Canada
and the United States (Dorais, 1989; Phan Van Phuoc, personal interview, July 14, 1996).
Protestants - Protestant groups constitute a very small minority
- less than one percent - of the population of Vietnam (Rev. Minh Ho, personal interview,
May 21, 1997). The proportion of Vietnamese Protestants in North America is likely higher,
though the numbers are difficult to estimate. Some of the Christian churches involved in
work at the refugee camps have attracted new Vietnamese adherents. In addition, some
Protestant denominations in North America have actively targeted their evangelization
efforts towards the Vietnamese population. The Christian and Missionary Alliance (CMA) has
engaged in missionary work in Vietnam since the early part of the 20th century.
The majority of Vietnamese Protestant congregations in Canada are affiliated with the CMA
church. Vietnamese Mennonite, Baptist, and Lutheran congregations also have formed in a
few Canadian cities (Rev. Binh Nguyen, Personal Interview, July 10, 1997).
SUMMARY
The Vietnamese people are united by a common language and a
collective family system which has its basis in a coalescence of Buddhist, Taoist, and
Confucian philosophical systems. However, numerous cleavages have long been present in
Vietnamese society. Ethnicity, urban or rural residence, region of origin, and religious
affiliation are sources of considerable social and class differentiation among the
population originating from Vietnam. Persons of Vietnamese origin bring diverse family and
personal histories with them to North America. This internal heterogeneity has important
implications not only for the formation and composition of ethnic diaspora
"communities" but also for the interactions of segments of the population with
the institutional sectors of the host society including the housing market, the labour
market, and the criminal justice system.
To
Chapter 4
Abstract/Acknowledgements/Table
of Contents - [ Chapters - 1 - 2 - 3 - 4 - 5 - 6 - 7 - 8 - 9 - 10 - 11 ] - Appendices - References
Cited
Back
to Top
|